I just got back from our winter college tour with our upperclassmen students. This is a special time for PA and his students to go look at schools, and spend “ubertime” investing in our relationship. I think the tour is a huge reason we’ve retained almost all of our upperclassmen in the youth group.
With that in mind, he is what I thought of one the school we visited.
Calvin College: Calvin was about 100% cooler than I thought it would be. I could tell that my students didn’t like it because it was a little too free for them. They were polite and impressed at times, but they didn’t like it at all.
Some things I did like. I liked the quality and size of the campus. It is a sizeable school. There are 4200 undergrad students and the campus is very nice. I liked the obvious girth and quality of the buildings. There weren’t any buildings that were run down or unattractive. It was clear academics reign supreme on campus. They don’t pump it up, you can feel it. It was clear that this was a place of academic excellence, and you don’t always feel that on the campuses we visit.
I loved the communications building and the cool little bridge to get over there. That whole thing was incredible. If I wanted to study that… I would go there. I also loved the engineering building. The studio-like space of the building just made you feel creative. As the tour guide said, “these guys do a lot more with engineering than just blow stuff up… But they do a lot of that too.”
Some things I didn’t like. They do something really stupid that our waitress at a nearby restaurant pointed out, (Proud alumni not using her degree!) they have “racial diversity as a core value” but then they segregate the campus. They allow students to choose to live on a multicultural floor in the dorms… But isn’t this just a cute way to segregate all the diversity in the name of multiculturalism? As our waitress pointed out “it’s obvious that they keep the blacks on certain floors.” Oops. Looks like that backfired! I don’t like that they advertise themselves as a Christian college but don’t require that students are Christians. I recognize the philosophy, but it has failed. Calvin is largely a secular college in the same way Notre Dame is.
Other things my students pointed out as huge negatives. Smoking! There were ample students smoking all over the place, usually around the doors to buildings. They said, if it’s like this when it is 13 degrees, imagine how nasty it is when it’s 63!
Another big bad thing, My students didn’t like the sexually charged/lax dorms. As we walked through my girls were very turned off that girls had written on the boys dorms doors stuff like “Ryan, I want to lay ya” or “got some sex in here.” One of my junior girls, who was huge on Calvin before visiting, said “I wouldn’t want to live in dorms where I didn’t feel safe. I’d feel better living in dorms where guys weren’t allowed.” A good and valid point from a girl who is trying to stay pure before marriage. Who wants to feel broken down on a “Christian campus?” If the dorms are like that then you might as well save $15k a year and go to Michigan State.
Overall, Calvin was much cooler than I thought it was. I could see myself there. But it was clear that the students of Light Force were unimpressed.