• Another reason I’m labeled a liberal

    I am the most liberal conservative you’ll ever meet. Or at least that’s how I often feel labeled. During my time at Moody I was taught and bought into a fairly conservative hermeneutic. In other words, how I read and interpret Scripture is through the lens of the original reader literally, than contextualizing it to today. “What did this mean to the original reader? How does this apply in our culture today?” People want to know where my radical views come from? They come from that! I believe the Bible is absolutely true… even when our religious culture disagrees.

    Interestingly, during my time in college I found myself differentiating with my alma mater on two major issues… based upon their own hermeneutic. So the tools that they equipped me with pretty much destroyed two of their positions for me!

    #1 A strict pretribulational interpretation of the book of Revelation. While I don’t reject this view entirely, the hermeneutical gymnastics scholars go through to get to this view is astounding. When my fellow students questioned this in our undergrad Daniel/Revelation class we were reminded that we were stupid and anyone intelligent would see that this was the only viable explanation. “It’s my role to indoctrinate you to teach this position to others” (To paraphrase the professor) Wow, not exactly the scholarship I knew elsewhere! Thankfully, I’ve learned that most conservative evangelicals agree with Yogi Berra. “It’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future.”

    #2 A sexist view on women in ministry. I know many in conservative evangelicalism firmly believe women shouldn’t be pastors and a woman’s role is to be subservient to men. I would agree if Scripture agreed! But there is simply no way one can hold this view using a Historical-grammatical interpretation of the Bible. With certain passages you may be able to intitially come to that conclusion… until you get to the last step. “Does this passage agree with the fullness of Scripture?” Clearly, Jesus’ life demonstrated that he did not come to lift women to a lower level than men. In fact, he consistently broke cultural boundaries in elevating women.

    This leads me to another reason I am proud not to be labeled a Baptist. I believe within some baptistic denominations is deep-seeded sexism. When it comes down to it, a woman can serve in every pastoral duty practically but not professionally. Biblical counseling, lead ministry programs, lead Bible studies, on and on. But women are not permitted to be called Pastors nor be compensated like their male counterparts. Nor are women allowed into some seminaries where they can earn an equal voice… which leads to men speaking for women on sensitive issues. Even among my own beloved alma mater, in 2008 a woman cannot be a student in the pastoral major without segregation into “womens ministry.” In most conservative congregations a woman can practically be a deacon or elder doing day-to-day things but cannot hold the postion purely because of her gender. In many congregations the most qualified candidates to lead ministries and hold positions are passed over purely because of gender. For me, this is a church sanctioned injustice that holds back many congregations from experiencing true health.

    I earned my card to hold a conservative evangelical credential. Academically and practically no one can claim I have not. But if being a card carrying conservative evangelical means I have to buy into group think where the men make all the decisions for women… it may be time for me to put my card on Ebay.

  • Two trends in ministry blogs

    I don’t know about you. But I read a ton of blogs every day. Here are two trends I’m seeing a lot of.

    #1 Senior pastors hyping their new series. Every one of their series is “incredible” or “the most important I’ve ever done.” Call me a cynic but I really doubt it. If you have to hype your own series on your blog something tells me you need to re-examine your churches marketing plan.

    #2 Talking about social networking tools. How to use facebook and twitter. And also, I see a lot of trend jumping as people who want to be hip are pimping out “the new thing” that may take off. I kind of think people do this because they want to be known as the person who was in early on the next facebook or twitter.

  • An offering of fish and loaves

    An offering of fish and loaves

    As you can tell, the last few posts have been openly questioning the paradigm of American Evangelicalism. Does the Gospel need buildings? Does the Gospel need money? And today I want to ask if the Gospel requires a tithe of cash.

    Let’s state the obvious right up front. Kristen and I tithe. We aren’t staunch legalists so I can’t say we give exactly 10% of our income away. To our local church we give a set weekly amount. We also support some missionaries monthly. And we do other things, as needed, on top of that. As someone who earned 100% of his living from local churches for the last several years, I’m a big fan of giving to the local church. If you don’t give and you can, please do. This post isn’t asking people not to give. It’s asking what we should do when people can’t give.

    We are entering a season in America in which our people will simply have to wrestle with money in ways they may never have. For most adults they probably have not wrestled with money this much since college. With inflation in every area of the economy people are having to chose between paying their mortgage/rent and buying gas for their car to get to work. In the same way, they are having to chose between giving to their church and buying groceries. To me, this creates a crisis for the church. And I wonder how ministers will speak truth into the lives of their people.

    I use the word crisis intentionally. This goes back to my fundamental belief that every crisis is an opportunity. And every crisis will create vast success for those who innovate solutions.

    On the one hand, we love people whether they give financially or not. At least we say we do. But we know, definitively, that giving to God is not tied to God’s benevelent love. And it would be completely sick if people were punished because they once gave and now cannot. (I know a couple people who would argue that their inability to give somehow disqualifies a person to hold a leadership position.)

    On the other hand, I wonder if the tithe has to be cash. Are we prepared to tell our people, “I know you can’t give because you got laid off. Would you be willing to tithe your talents? Would you be willing to tithe your time?”

    I am openly questioning if paid people in ministry are so worried that giving will shrink to the point that they will lose their paychecks that they not comforting the suddenly poor. I am worried that church leaders will be so desperate for income that they will skew what the Bible says for their own gain. And I’m openly wondering if the church is willing to think of a new way to make an offering to God. Will you still love Joe the Plumber when he becomes Joe the Gas Station Attendant?

    The more I think about this the more I am convinced that we, as Evangelicals, are missing something. I think we’ve so engrained ourselves into the lie of the American dream that we have warped the Gospel to being a game of bigger and better. If God is blessing a church, it’ll get bigger. Offerings will go up. We can hire more staff and build bigger buildings. What if God blessed the church by making it smaller?

  • The church of no money

    You’d have to live under a rock to not know that our country is in trouble financially. Voices like Dave Ramsey and Suze Orman just weren’t loud enough and our nation has basically credited itself to death. Amazingly, I’m not seeing any Christian blogger asking the most obvious question, “What will happen to our church when people stop giving?”

    Here’s the deal. The almighty dollar greatly matters to the church. From big buildings, to big salaries, to big spending ministries. The American evangelical church loves to collect and spend money. I don’t think that’s arguable.

    So, what’s going to happen when people stop giving money? We talked about this last night in community group. For whatever reason most people consider giving to their church to come from their discretionary income pocket. It’s important… but not as important as paying bills. Whether or not that is biblically right or not really isn’t the issue. The issue is that people give out of discretionary money. And now that huge segments of givers are loosing their ability to spend any discretionary money, the church will suffer big time. Missionaries and non-profits will feel it first.. they already are. Even the best planning, best savings, and best stewardship may not be able to make it through. I know of a megachurch in Michigan that has 12 months in reserves. I don’t think that will be enough.

    As churches fail to meet payroll a crisis may emerge. And like any crisis the wise will see it as an opportunity. What is true in business will be true in the church… out of crisis will come the best innovation!

    Tony Campolo touched this a litte at NYWC Sacramento. And it got me thinking… what will the church of no money look like? Tony paralleled it to the church in China after the Boxer Revolution. Surely, the church of Jesus Christ will prevail! But what will it look like?

    Thoughts? I’d love to hear them.

  • The Chicago Edition

    Each week I have fun shooting the podcast. But this particular episode was special because we had the opportunity to do a Chicago special.

    The concept of a Chicago special really didn’t come to me until Cathy and I got off the plane in Chicago. We had Andrew Marin booked to do the devotional and I knew I wanted to shoot my parts at North Avenue beach… then it hit me. If we added Jason Raitz from Willow Creek we could complete the Chicago-trifecta. Thankfully, Jason was able to squeeze us in. And just to show us he was a pro he did his segment in one take.

    Some tidbits about this episode…

    We shot Andrew Marin’s part on the rooftop deck of his condo. Technically, we walked past his deck to the unfenced part so we could shoot the city in the background with no fencing. If you look carefully… behind Andrew is Wrigley Field. Cathy went up there with me even though she is afraid of heights. We were about 15 floors off the ground, Andrew sat down about 5 feet from the edge… and Cathy stayed back a good 20 feet taking pictures. She was a trooper!

    Then we drove over to North Avenue beach.
    When Kristen and I first started dating this was a favorite spot. In fact, just 100 yards north of where I shot my parts Kristen and I had our first real date. Romeo students will recognize that spot as well, we always took our mission team photo right there.

    From there, we went out to Willow Creek to meet Jason. I’ve known Jason a few years and I really love his passion for middle school students. The thing a lot of people probably don’t know about Willow is that while they have massive middle and high school ministries, they are 99% run by volunteers. As Jason shares in the podcast, a big part of his role is setting up those volunteers to lead small groups. With a staff of 4-5 full time folks they lead something like 1700 middle schoolers. Think about that… 4-5 adults oversee an organization that impacts 4-5k people any given month, including parents.

    When it was all said and done, shooting this 11 minute video and all the travel time was about 12 hours of our day. Totally worth it. I hope we get to do more location-based podcasts soon.

  • The Mission of Less

    Planet Wisdom Chicago was great. 2000 kids slammed into a building to be challenged by the word of God is always awesome. Going into it I knew that the team was passionate about the conference and I saw first hand why. It’s really cool! Lives were changed. It doesn’t get any better than that.

    At the same time I felt really challenged by the church that hosted. It was one of those brand new megachurch $10 million deals. I don’t know how long it has been open but it was massive and it was gorgeous. It had that new church smell. And I thought to myself, “I’m glad I am not on the leadership team of this church.” I would never question the integrity of a church leadership team and I am certainly not doing so now. Yet, I wondered how I would process the excess as it correlates to the excessive need of the gospel in their community. Would I have stood behind the decision to build? This is more a reflection of where I am in my walk with the Lord than it is an indictment on a church. In fact, I want to fully acknowledge that I am positive that it’s a great building for them. And I want to make it clear that I am positive the gospel is advanced as a result of that church. And this post has way more to do with big church buildings generally than it does the particular church who hosted us. Moreover, driving around the Chicago suburbs that particular church merely did what dozens of others did… build a bigger building to better suit their needs. OK, enough apologizing for what I’m about to say!

    Here’s what I was left thinking about. For $10 million how many churches could they have planted in their community? For $10 million how many kids could they mentor at the local schools? For $10 million how many homeless people could they feed? How many families could they help? Assuming they paid cash for the building, for the $10,000-$20,000 per month it likely costs to heat, cool, and light the building how much kingdom work are they prevented from doing with those same dollars?

    Now that we go to a church with no building, my perspective has changed. All of my life I’ve said “the church is the people and not the building.” And yet fiscally, the churches finances reflect that the church is the building and the staff. (90% of spending, more or less.) When a person diverts giving to advance the kingdom, a building based church says “No, that money needs to pay our light bill! We have staff to pay!” And as a result the kingdom work the Holy Spirit has compelled a giver to give towards is thwarted by a churches building needs. Now that we go to a church with no building, we can worry about building the kingdom of God in our community and not a building. It’s freeing and wonderful and we are thankful for this time that God has placed us here.

    As I’ve shared before, my perspective on big fancy churches always makes me think of my time in Europe. Congregations spent generations building trillion dollar cathedrals that are largely empty today. They were so busy showing their community that they were the city on a hill that they forgot to be the city on the hill!

    What do you think? Is a big, nice building needed to advance the gospel? Or is it preventing the people from being the church?

  • Take me home

    There is no glamor in business travel. I would never want anyone to think that I don’t genuinely love my job or meeting so many cool people, because I totally do. And I am always fully aware that a ton of people would die to do what I do every day… God continues to grant me undeserved favor. Yet, there is nothing quite as wonderful as knowing that today is the day I am going home.

    Home.

    Romeo people will jump on that. It is true, San Diego is now where I think of as home. Forget that idea that “home is where you hang your hat.” Well, it is true if by hat you mean my wife and kids! It’s not like I hung Kristen, Megan, and Paul on a hook and they just chill at the house waiting for me to come back. They are home doing stuff while I’m away… doing really fun stuff like going to the zoo, or a museum, or taking the dog to the vet. Their life doesn’t stop… it just carries on without me.

    Another thing about going home is that I need to take care of stuff. I’m sure hard core business travelers are better at this than I am. But when I’m away I always forget to pay my bills! While I think that is funny, something tells me that there are some companies kind of wishing I would send them some money.

    So, in just a couple hours I head back to Midway and fly home. Loved Chicago. Loved Planet Wisdom. Ready to get 10 days at home before Pittsburgh.

  • Saturday Tunes

    This morning finds me in a hotel in the suburbs of Chicago. Yesterday was a fun day with a ton of driving. We ran all over the city filming Monday’s YS Podcast. Lakeview, the Loop, the Lake, and South Barrington. It’ll be a great episode that I can’t wait to send out on Monday.

    Today, I’ll be attending day two of Planet Wisdom Chicago. The first night was great. I had never been to one and I was really impressed. I knew the second session would have a calling to follow Christ and I was interested to see how they did that… loved it. The least manipulative I’ve ever seen and yet dozens of kids responded.

    Music is always part of my day. Here are the next 10 tunes rolling off my iPod this morning. As always, no cheating and ratings included.

    #1 Smile by U2 ****

    #2 Baby O’Riley by The Who *****

    #3 Golden Slumbers from the Happy Feet Soundtrack ****

    #4 Breathrough by Brook Berretsmith *

    #5 The Riddle by Five for Fighting ****

    #6 Questions by Jason Harwell ****

    #7 Fivetweezy by KJ-52 ****

    #8 Let’s Dance to the Joy Division by The Wombats *****

    #9 Goodbye George by Sandra McCracken ****

    #10 O Praise Him by David Crowder Band ****

  • YS podcast: Adam’s Ghetto Version

    Literally, we shot this podcast on our handheld cameras and my Macbook’s isight camera. Pay attention to the intro and it will make perfect sense.